Did anything change?

Share

We have a new county commission board... and a new chair. Let's talk about it.

As expected, commissioner Janet Barek was skipped from being appointed chair. She simply does not have support from her colleagues... likely because she keeps calling them out and questioning them. However, that is what she was elected to do in the first place.

She is an outsider. She is not in any political circles. She is honest to a fault. She tells it like she sees it. She was elected to be that person and she is doing what the voters want her to do. But that ruffles feathers. She is a thorn in the side and as such, not well liked the others.

But that doesnt mean she cannot run an effective meeting. That is largely what the chair position does. They are in charge of the meetings. They are also the "face" so to speak of the board, but the chair does not have any more power than anyone else.

Just because you do not like someone doesn't mean that they cannot run a meeting and keep it on track. Just because she is more vocal about issues does not mean that she gets extra power to do things that the others do not get to do.

The chair makes sure the meeting order is followed. They ask for the votes/motions. They cut people off at the microphone for going past their allotted time. They have some latitude in making some procedural decisions, like the order of people lining up for public comment, but those things can be overruled by the board as a whole.

In other words... no real reason to not give her the chair... unless they just do not want to hear her voice the entire meeting... or some other motive.

The nominations started with commissioner Kinnard jumping out to make a motion to nominate new commissioner Stacey Worthington.

She read a prepared statement that gave things that she looked for in a chair... then ultimately said she did not meet her own criteria.

Apparently, she did not know she was going to be nominated... however, not sure I believe that.

Remember.. she is VERY close with former commissioner Ruthie Schlabach... so close in fact that Ruthie held signs for her... mentioned things publicly about her opponent Diana Finegan... went to the meeting yesterday to show support... and went to a celebration party last night for Worthington.

They are tight.

You know who else is close with Ruthie? Kinnard's wife, Renee. She is also very active behind the scenes in regards to her husband's commissioner position. She runs his social media page.

Is it a coincidence then that Kinnard is the one out of the gate to nominate a newly elected commissioner as chair? When was the last time a newly elected commissioner was nominated to the chair position? I cannot think of one.

So why now? As Kinnard would state, she has experience chairing the PDC and felt she would do a good job at the BOCC... but running meetings for the county is a bit different than for the PDC... and again.. generally there is a routine that is followed.

Kinda odd for him to nominate Worthington... but she declined it and said she was not fit for that position at the moment.

Commissioner Holly Davis then nominated Kinnard. Commissioner Holli Herndon then nominated Barek.

The vote was called for Kinnard first and he won 3-2... with support from Davis and Worthington, along with himself.

But before the vote... Kinnard went on a rant on why Barek could not get his support and did not deserve the chair position.

1) She has not demonstrated the ability to bring opposing positions together

2) She has been argumentative from the dais.

3) She has threatened the jobs of two employees in the county... which he says violates county ordinances on interference with staff and may violate state statutes on that as well.

4) He mentioned other reasons but did not elaborate.

We talked a bit about #1 and #2. She is doing what she was elected to do. Voters did not want the status quo. They chose an outsider to be an outsider and represent them as such. She is doing a good job at that... which means she is often on the losing end of 4-1 or 3-2 votes.

Again... does not help her cause when she is always disagreeing with colleagues... but also... that is what she was elected to do... and her supporters wanted her on the chair position.

But I want to focus on #3.

Kinnard said she is violating county ordinances for interference and that is a reason to not support her.

Yet... the board voted for Kinnard. He is far from perfect.

1) He voted to approve the agenda item regarding Betz Farm back in May when the county attorney told them that it violated county ordinances.

2) He ignored a commissioner violating county ordinances when she went directly to staff to have them sign forms for a state appropriation for 491 outside of board direction.

3) He lied during the quasi judicial hearing for the VA Clinic when he said that he did not have ex-parte communication to disclose despite him having phone calls and a teams call with the developers.

4) He sat quietly when a previous chair would silence members of the public as they were speaking at the podium during open to the public... violating their first amendment rights.

5) He violated administrative regulations a few weeks ago by moving his agenda item to the consent agenda, despite it not being an item that qualified for the consent agenda according to county administrative regulations.

6) He tried to fast track the sand mine in Pine Ridge and skip the public process to help FDOT get their sand for the parkway and only backed down due to public pressure.

And most of those things are just this year. All are violations of county ordinances or administrative regulations... but I guess they do not apply to him.

The hypocrisy of that comment is astounding.

But 3 of them are so against Barek that no one called him out on any of that... They are also in the same circle so I would not expect them to either... which goes back to the problem we have in this county... when it is a "friend" it is ok to turn a blind eye... when it is someone pushing against that group... it is time to call them out.

We will see how all this comes together, but yesterday gave you a pretty good indication of what to expect... Largely the same board makeup we had before, but different faces in the seats.